Both smoking traditional tobacco cigarettes and vaping involve the inhalation of substances, but they differ markedly in their composition and health implications.
This article looks at vaping vs smoking, drawing on current research and official guidelines to determine which option poses fewer risks to your health.
Understanding Vaping and Smoking
Smoking traditional tobacco cigarettes involves inhaling a cocktail of harmful chemicals into the lungs, including tar, carbon monoxide and nicotine.
This toxic combination contributes to numerous health problems. It has been linked to a variety of serious diseases, such as lung cancer, heart disease and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), among others.
Vaping involves inhaling vapour produced by an electronic device known as an e-cigarette or vape pen. These devices heat a liquid called e-liquid containing nicotine, flavourings and other chemicals.
Unlike smoking, vaping does not produce tar or carbon monoxide, making it a less harmful alternative for those seeking to quit traditional smoking. It is reported to be up to 95% less harmful than regular cigarettes.
Smoking Vs Vaping Health Risks
Cancer
Tobacco Smoking – According to Cancer Research UK, ‘tobacco is the biggest cause of cancer in the world.’ Chemicals in tobacco smoke are known to damage DNA and promote tumour growth, causing fifteen different types of cancer, including lung, throat, mouth, oesophagus and stomach cancer.
Vaping – E-cigarettes present a potentially less harmful alternative to smoking in terms of cancer risk due to the absence of combustion. Despite some potential side effects like throat and mouth irritation and coughing, these are typically less severe than those from smoking.
However, comprehensive regulation and ongoing research are crucial to understanding the long-term health impacts of vaping entirely and to promote informed public health strategies.
As a result, the arteries carrying blood to the heart and brain can get clogged, increasing the risk of a heart attack or stroke. Smoking tobacco can also raise blood pressure and heart rate, reduce oxygen supply and increase the risk of blood clots and damaged blood vessels.
Vaping – With regards to smoking vs vaping, vaping is viewed as a safer option than traditional smoking, especially regarding cardiovascular health. While vaping’s nicotine content can still affect heart rate and blood pressure in those with existing heart disease, research indicates it’s ‘not a significant health hazard for people without heart conditions.’ Therefore, for smokers struggling to quit, vaping could serve as a harm-reduction alternative.
Respiratory Issues
Tobacco Smoking – Regularly breathing in smoke damages, irritates and inflames the airways. Over time, the tar in cigarette smoke damages the lungs, making it harder for air to get in and out of the lungs. This leads to chronic respiratory issues such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Smoking long-term can also increase the risk of asthma and infections like pneumonia.
Vaping – There has been speculation in the media that vaping causes popcorn lung. However, the NHS and Cancer Research strongly assert that vaping does not cause bronchiolitis obliterans and that the culprit is the substance diacetyl, which is found in some flavoured e-liquids to enhance a buttery flavour. As diacetyl has been banned in e-cigarettes since 2016, consumers are likely not to develop popcorn lung. Yet, vaping can cause inflammation of the airway, leading many who have asthma to experience flare-ups.
Addiction
Tobacco Smoking – Nicotine rapidly enters the bloodstream through the lungs, reaching the brain within seconds and releasing neurotransmitters like dopamine, which reinforce addictive behaviour. This dependency can lead to increased stress, anxiety and mood disorders.
Vaping – Though the UK government states that vapes ‘provide lower nicotine levels to users,’ it can still potentially impact brain development in adolescents and young adults. Despite these risks, it is recognised as a safer alternative to traditional smoking and is endorsed by the NHS as an effective method to assist smokers in quitting.
Tobacco e-liquids, including those naturally extracted from tobacco leaves (NETs), provide a smoother transition for quitting smokers by mimicking the flavour without the combustion. This approach avoids the harmful byproducts associated with burning tobacco, offering a healthier alternative and helping to manage withdrawal symptoms more effectively.
To Conclude
When discussing smoking vs vaping, it is clear that neither option is entirely without health risks. However, vaping is generally considered less harmful than smoking traditional cigarettes.
Attempting to quit tobacco smoking can lead to withdrawal symptoms such as irritability, difficulty concentrating and intense cravings, which can exacerbate psychological distress and perpetuate the cycle of addiction. Therefore, vaping should only be started by individuals who wish to stop smoking and will use vaping as an aid to quit.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok
Vaping vs Smoking – Which is Better for Your Health?
Both smoking traditional tobacco cigarettes and vaping involve the inhalation of substances, but they differ markedly in their composition and health implications.
This article looks at vaping vs smoking, drawing on current research and official guidelines to determine which option poses fewer risks to your health.
Understanding Vaping and Smoking
Smoking traditional tobacco cigarettes involves inhaling a cocktail of harmful chemicals into the lungs, including tar, carbon monoxide and nicotine.
This toxic combination contributes to numerous health problems. It has been linked to a variety of serious diseases, such as lung cancer, heart disease and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), among others.
Vaping involves inhaling vapour produced by an electronic device known as an e-cigarette or vape pen. These devices heat a liquid called e-liquid containing nicotine, flavourings and other chemicals.
Unlike smoking, vaping does not produce tar or carbon monoxide, making it a less harmful alternative for those seeking to quit traditional smoking. It is reported to be up to 95% less harmful than regular cigarettes.
Smoking Vs Vaping Health Risks
Cancer
Tobacco Smoking – According to Cancer Research UK, ‘tobacco is the biggest cause of cancer in the world.’ Chemicals in tobacco smoke are known to damage DNA and promote tumour growth, causing fifteen different types of cancer, including lung, throat, mouth, oesophagus and stomach cancer.
Vaping – E-cigarettes present a potentially less harmful alternative to smoking in terms of cancer risk due to the absence of combustion. Despite some potential side effects like throat and mouth irritation and coughing, these are typically less severe than those from smoking.
However, comprehensive regulation and ongoing research are crucial to understanding the long-term health impacts of vaping entirely and to promote informed public health strategies.
Cardiovascular Disease
Tobacco Smoking – According to the British Heart Foundation, ‘smoking-related diseases account for around 100,000 deaths each year in the UK.’ Not only do the chemicals in cigarettes cause cancer, but the tar found in tobacco smoking can make the walls of the arteries sticky.
As a result, the arteries carrying blood to the heart and brain can get clogged, increasing the risk of a heart attack or stroke. Smoking tobacco can also raise blood pressure and heart rate, reduce oxygen supply and increase the risk of blood clots and damaged blood vessels.
Vaping – With regards to smoking vs vaping, vaping is viewed as a safer option than traditional smoking, especially regarding cardiovascular health. While vaping’s nicotine content can still affect heart rate and blood pressure in those with existing heart disease, research indicates it’s ‘not a significant health hazard for people without heart conditions.’ Therefore, for smokers struggling to quit, vaping could serve as a harm-reduction alternative.
Respiratory Issues
Tobacco Smoking – Regularly breathing in smoke damages, irritates and inflames the airways. Over time, the tar in cigarette smoke damages the lungs, making it harder for air to get in and out of the lungs. This leads to chronic respiratory issues such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Smoking long-term can also increase the risk of asthma and infections like pneumonia.
Vaping – There has been speculation in the media that vaping causes popcorn lung. However, the NHS and Cancer Research strongly assert that vaping does not cause bronchiolitis obliterans and that the culprit is the substance diacetyl, which is found in some flavoured e-liquids to enhance a buttery flavour. As diacetyl has been banned in e-cigarettes since 2016, consumers are likely not to develop popcorn lung. Yet, vaping can cause inflammation of the airway, leading many who have asthma to experience flare-ups.
Addiction
Tobacco Smoking – Nicotine rapidly enters the bloodstream through the lungs, reaching the brain within seconds and releasing neurotransmitters like dopamine, which reinforce addictive behaviour. This dependency can lead to increased stress, anxiety and mood disorders.
Vaping – Though the UK government states that vapes ‘provide lower nicotine levels to users,’ it can still potentially impact brain development in adolescents and young adults. Despite these risks, it is recognised as a safer alternative to traditional smoking and is endorsed by the NHS as an effective method to assist smokers in quitting.
Tobacco e-liquids, including those naturally extracted from tobacco leaves (NETs), provide a smoother transition for quitting smokers by mimicking the flavour without the combustion. This approach avoids the harmful byproducts associated with burning tobacco, offering a healthier alternative and helping to manage withdrawal symptoms more effectively.
To Conclude
When discussing smoking vs vaping, it is clear that neither option is entirely without health risks. However, vaping is generally considered less harmful than smoking traditional cigarettes.
Attempting to quit tobacco smoking can lead to withdrawal symptoms such as irritability, difficulty concentrating and intense cravings, which can exacerbate psychological distress and perpetuate the cycle of addiction. Therefore, vaping should only be started by individuals who wish to stop smoking and will use vaping as an aid to quit.